How to choose an insurance broker: 7 questions to ask before you sign
By Zach Nadler·I'm a fourth-generation insurance broker. My great-grandfather started this agency in 1927. My grandfather grew it. My dad has been doing this for over 50 years. And I still meet people every week who picked their broker the same way they'd pick a restaurant: a quick Google search, whoever shows up first, maybe a friend's recommendation.
That's not necessarily bad. But insurance isn't tacos. A wrong pick doesn't just leave you mildly disappointed. It can leave you uninsured when you need coverage most.
So here are 7 questions to ask before you sign with anyone. Including us.
1. Are you independent or captive?
This is the single most important question and most people don't know to ask it.
A captive agent works for one insurance company. They sell that company's products. That's it. State Farm, Allstate, Farmers: if you're working with one of their agents, you're getting quotes from one carrier.
An independent broker represents multiple carriers. We shop the market on your behalf (sometimes 10, 15, 20+ companies) to find the right coverage at the right price.
The difference matters most when:
Neither model is inherently evil. But you should know which one you're dealing with before you hand over your declarations pages.
2. How do you get paid?
Most brokers and agents earn a commission, a percentage of your premium paid by the insurance carrier. You don't write them a separate check. The commission is baked into the premium whether you use an agent or buy direct.
Some brokers charge fees, either instead of or in addition to commissions. This is more common on commercial accounts.
Neither model is automatically better. But you should know:
A good broker will answer these questions without getting defensive. If they get weird about it, that tells you something.
3. What happens when I have a claim?
This is where the relationship gets tested. Before you sign, ask:
Some agencies hand you a claims phone number and wish you luck. Others pick up the phone, call the adjuster, and fight for your settlement.
At Nadler Insurance, my dad has been advocating for clients' claims for 50 years. He knows the adjusters. He knows the process. He knows when a carrier is lowballing. That's not something you get from a chatbot.
4. How often will you review my coverage?
Insurance isn't a "set it and forget it" product. Your life changes. Your assets change. Your risks change. A good broker should be proactively reviewing your coverage at least once a year, not just sending you a renewal notice and hoping you don't ask questions.
Ask:
If the answer is "we send you a renewal and you call us if you have questions," that's not a review. That's a transaction.
5. What do you specialize in?
Some brokers are generalists. Some specialize in commercial. Some focus on personal lines. Some know restaurants inside and out. Some have never written a restaurant in their life.
There's no wrong answer here, but there is a fit question. If you're a small business owner with complex commercial needs, a broker who primarily does personal auto and homeowners might not be the best match.
At our agency, we do both (personal and commercial) because we've always believed that when we insure your home, your cars, your umbrella, AND your business, we see the full picture. Gaps are easier to spot. Coverage is easier to coordinate.
But that's our philosophy. Ask your prospective broker what theirs is.
6. Can I actually reach you?
This sounds basic, but it's shockingly relevant. Ask:
Insurance is a service business. If you can't reach your agent when you need them, everything else is irrelevant.
I've heard stories from people who switched to us after spending a week trying to get a call back from their previous agent. A week. For a simple endorsement change. That's not acceptable in any industry, but in insurance (where timing can affect whether a claim is covered) it's inexcusable.
7. Why should I trust you with this?
This is the uncomfortable question. Ask it anyway.
A broker who can't articulate why they're the right fit for your specific situation probably isn't. You're not looking for a sales pitch. You're looking for a real answer:
When people ask me this question, I tell them the truth: we've been doing this since 1927. Four generations. We're not going anywhere. We pick up the phone. We know the carriers. We've handled claims for families whose grandparents were our clients.
That's not a pitch. That's a Tuesday.
The question most people forget to ask themselves
Before you evaluate any broker, ask yourself: What do I actually want from this relationship?
If you want the cheapest price and nothing else, a direct-to-consumer website will do that. No judgment.
But if you want someone who knows your name, reviews your coverage proactively, picks up the phone when something goes sideways, and actually understands what you're insuring, that's what a good broker does.
Not all brokers are the same. The questions you ask before you sign determine the experience you get after.
Zach Nadler is a 4th-generation insurance broker at Nadler Insurance in San Carlos, CA. Let's see if we're the right fit →